Is NSLS honor society a pyramid scheme?

I recently received an invitation to join the National Society of Leadership and Success (NSLS). I’ve seen conflicting online reviews, with some praising its benefits for college applications and others expressing concerns. I’m curious to hear from someone who has been a member of NSLS. Could you share your experience with the organization?

Thanks for bringing up this question! I’ve looked into NSLS extensively and have worked with students who’ve joined, so here’s my perspective.

First, NSLS (the National Society of Leadership and Success) is a legitimate organization, so it’s not a scam. However, it operates on a “pay-to-join” model, meaning you pay a membership fee to access the resources they offer, like leadership training, networking events, and scholarship opportunities. While some students find these benefits useful, it’s important to know that joining isn’t necessarily a sign of unique achievement or talent.

Admissions officers generally categorize memberships like NSLS as a Tier 4 extracurricular activity. This is the lowest tier in terms of impact because it doesn’t reflect significant leadership, long-term commitment, or a noteworthy accomplishment. Essentially, it’s something many students have on their resumes, so it doesn’t stand out to colleges.

That said, the value you get from NSLS depends on your goals. If you’re interested in the resources they provide—like leadership workshops or networking—and you think they align with your personal or professional development, it might be worth the membership fee. However, many of these same resources can often be found elsewhere for free or at a lower cost, such as through school clubs, local organizations, or online platforms.

My advice? If you’re trying to boost your college applications, focus your energy on activities where you can demonstrate leadership, dedication, and impact. For example, starting a club, holding an officer position in an organization, or volunteering in your community consistently over time will carry far more weight in the admissions process than a paid membership in NSLS.

If you do decide to join NSLS, make the most of it by actively engaging with their programs. But don’t rely on it as a standout feature for your college applications. Admissions officers are looking for depth and initiative, so seek out opportunities where you can really shine and leave a lasting impression.

I hope this helps you make an informed decision. Good luck, and feel free to ask if you have more questions about extracurriculars or college applications!